iXBT Labs :: Computer Hardware In Detail

Platform

Video

Multimedia

Mobile

Other

ATI Technologies' counter-offensive:
RADEON X1800 (R520),
X1600 (RV530), and X1300 (RV515) Series

Part 4: Rendering Quality, New Anti-Aliasing and Anisotropic Filtering Modes
(Continuation, DOOM 3)






TABLE OF CONTENTS

  1. Part 1. Theory and architecture
  2. Part 2: Practical examination
  3. Part 3: Game test results (performance)
  4. Part 4: Render quality comparison in games


Settings and conventional signs

  • AA and AF control was done from the game.
  • Drivers were configured by default, except for those modified to analyze the quality in various AA and AF modes.

  • 4x/16x = MSAA 4x, AF 16x
  • 4x+TA/16x = MSAA 4x + Transparency/Adaptive AA, AF 16x
  • 4x+TA/16x+HQ = MSAA 4x + Transparency/Adaptive AA, AF 16x High Quality (HQ AF and Catalyst A.I. Off in R520, Catalyst A.I. Off in R480 and HQ mode in G70)

Doom 3

The next important game to appear was Doom 3. Doom 3 is more unassuming than Far Cry in terms of its support for various features and functions, there is nothing excessive in its engine — only necessary things to create the game. In addition, Doom 3 is the only game in our review that uses API OpenGL.

Remember that ATI has not yet implemented Adaptive AA for OpenGL, so there is no antialiasing for transparent textures in Doom 3 on the RX1800. That's a vexatious issue. However, it's compensated by very few transparent textures in Doom 3.

 
Radeon X1800
GeForce 7800
4x/16x



JPEG (~530 KB) | PNG (~2.6 MB)



JPEG (~530 KB) | PNG (~2.6 MB)
4x+TA/16x



JPEG (~530 KB) | PNG (~2.6 MB)



JPEG (~530 KB) | PNG (~2.6 MB)
4x+TA/16x+HQ



JPEG (~530 KB) | PNG (~2.6 MB)



JPEG (~530 KB) | PNG (~2.6 MB)
 
Radeon X850
4x/16x



JPEG (~530 KB) | PNG (~2.6 MB)
4x+TA/16x
-
4x+TA/16x+HQ



JPEG (~530 KB) | PNG (~2.6 MB)

Not a trace remains of the unanimity in Far Cry. Pay attention how much worse GF7800 filters the grid texture on the floor than both Radeons — the GF7800 can match the RX1800 only in High Quality mode. In our opinion, trilinear filtering in the GF7800 remains "optimized" even in High Quality mode; at least, it obviously of lower quality than that in Radeon cards.

When Catalyst A.I. is disabled, both Radeon cards stop substituting a shader responsible for texture lighting. As a result, lighting changes and performance drops noticeably.

And again we see no special advantages of the new anisotropy algorithm in the R520. None can antialias semitransparent textures in this frame: for some reason, the central grid on the background remains unsmoothed not only on the RX1800, but on the GF7800 as well.

We have witnessed a strange artifact in Doom 3 on the RX1800: HQ anisotropy with active Catalyst A.I. is of lower quality than even the regular anisotropy. That's how it looks: a clearly visible line at the border of the texture and the first MIP level. So you'd better disable Catalyst A.I. to get back the normal HQ anisotropy:

Radeon X1800 HQ AF, AI On Radeon X1800 HQ AF, AI Off






Back: Far Cry | Forward: Half-Life 2

Andrey Vorobiev (anvakams@ixbt.com)
Danil Gridasov (degust@ixbt.com)

October 12, 2005.



Article navigation:



  Most Popular Reviews More   RSS  

Intel Core i5-660/661 Processors

The long-awaited dual-core solutions for the LGA1156 platform.
Jan 09, 2010 · Processors: Intel

AMD Athlon II X3 425, 435 Processors

Three cores for the price of two.
Oct 30, 2009 · Processors: AMD

E-MU 0404 USB

A top-class external audio interface.
Nov 23, 2006 · ProAudio

Intel H55, H57 Chipsets

Integrated chipsets for lower-end Nehalem processors.
Jan 18, 2010 · Chipsets

Creative Sound Blaster X-Fi Surround 5.1

An external X-Fi solution in tests.
Sep 09, 2008 · Sound Cards
  Latest Reviews More   RSS  

ASUS M4A785G HTPC/RC Motherboard

A microATX board with a high-quality audio codec and a remote.
Feb 05, 2010 · Motherboards

Thermaltake Element G Mid Tower Case

Compact size, fan controller, and stylish lights.
Feb 03, 2010 · General Platform

ATI RADEON HD 5670 Graphics Card

A low-end solution with DirectX 11 support.
Feb 02, 2010 · Video cards: ATI GPUs

i3DSpeed, January 2010

Updated the list of benchmarks. Added test results for Radeon HD 5670.
Feb 01, 2010 · 3Digests

Intel Celeron E3300 Processor

A full-fledged low-end solution or a "socket stub?"
Jan 29, 2010 · Processors: Intel
  Latest News More   RSS  
 
  Useful Links Get listed  

Platform  ·  Video  ·  Multimedia  ·  Mobile  ·  Other  ·  Compare Prices  ||  Feedback  ·  Advertise at iXBT Labs  ·  About us  ·  Affiliates  ·  Forum


45

Copyright © Byrds Research & Publishing, Ltd., 1997—2010. All rights reserved.