iXBT Labs :: Computer Hardware In Detail

Platform

Video

Multimedia

Mobile

Other

Transcend Ultra 45x CompactFlash Card Review


 

 Forum


It was known that Transcend planned on making new CompactFlash cards on a new controller when I worked on the previous part of the flash card tests. The reason was simple: the speed characteristics were always very important for the company and it didn't want to leave the leading position for long. Last summer when I just started the tests, Transcend Ultra 25x was the fastest but the competitors were close on the heels. Then we got the Apacer Photo Sceno Pro with greater read and write speeds. The Ultra 30x was Transcend's response. The speed wasn't lifted considerably, but it was enough to grasp the power once again. At the same time, and it's even more important, it had improved compatibility with many models of digicams. This card became the best choice for demanding users for a pretty long period.

But time flies. Delkin Devices eFilm Pro card released this year broke new records, and PQI's F1 launched by summer improved the write speed even more (though its read speed was lower than that of Delkin's card). The read speed approached 6 MB/s and the write one nearly reached 5 MB/s (at least, on our testbed). The progress was considerable. That was Transcend's time to lift its speeds :)
 







For the 30x cards the company changed only the sticker leaving the same card design. But the growth to 45x looks much more significant (50% against 20%), and now one would hardly confuse the new cards with the old ones even in color.

As you can see, we tested a 1GB card. Transcend also offers twice smaller and twice greater cards (in size), with the production volume of the 512MB model being the lowest. A couple of gigabytes is cool but the price is also pretty high. The card makers started a race for volume, and I must say that it's not just volume increase, - they do it to the detriment of the most popular card sizes.

I hope our readers can afford 1GB and maybe even 2MB cards without selling their property :). Or at least, 512 MB cards will be supplied in greater quantities. 

So, we tested the card in the 6-in-1 IEEE1394 connected to the FireWire controller on the SB Audigy under the Windows XP Pro Rus SP1 with the HD Tach 2.61. Such test system was used in the last two parts of the flash card tests. I also wanted to include this card into the third part, but it's not finished yet as other new solutions appear irregularly, while Transcend's 45x card is already available. Apart from the overall situation on the market we'll also estimate how faster this card is compared to the old one.

The access time is even a little greater, and I can't say it looks perfect in comparison with the rest. However, the access time doesn't exceed 1.5 ms for all modern GF cards, which is incomparable to the Microdrive or the like, and the difference lower than 1 ms is not critical in most cases.

6 MB/s! The card outscores the former leader and takes the palm of supremacy. 5% is a significant gap. 30% over the 30x is not that bad, and we actually didn't expect 50% promised :) 

Also, this is the first card that reaches 5 MB/s in writing. The breakaway is not great, but in this case every 50 KB/s can be determining (like it was last time). The new Transcend outpaces the former leader by 200 KB/s which is a pure victory. As compared to the previous solution, the growth is over 20% - it's farther from promised 50% even more but... In some other spheres new models can be equal in speed or even slower than the old models, and in the sector of flash cards the speeds grow up all the time. They grow either gradually like in case of the CompactFlash or stepwise like in case of the SD. 

Well, Transcend demonstrated its power once again. From time to time its cards lose the leading position as the other companies do not dawdle either, but every new iteration makes it a leader once again. This time the picture is the same - I don't see any competitors for the Ultra 45x, and even if they soon come onto the scene owners of the new cards won't be losers.
  
 

Andrei Kozhemyako aka Korzh (korzh@ixbt.com




  Most Popular Reviews More   RSS  
March 2, 2009 · Processors: AMD

AMD Phenom II X4 940 Overclocking
With various motherboards. How it affects games.

May 15, 2009 · System Memory

Phenom II Processors and DDR3 Memory
What are the benefits of moving to DDR3?

February 16, 2009 · Processors: AMD

AMD Phenom II X3 720 / X4 810 / X4 920 Processors
Aimed at leadership in the budget segment.

June 3, 2009 · Processors: Intel

Intel Core i7 950 Processor
Original, but not surprising.

May 27, 2009 · Processors: Intel

Intel Core 2 with Various FSB / Memory Clock Rates
What memory clock rate can uncover Core 2 potential?

  Latest Reviews More   RSS  
June 26, 2009 · Coolers

Five Premium CPU Coolers In Tests
From ASUS, Noctua, Scythe, Thermalright and Thermaltake.

June 22, 2009 · Video cards: NVIDIA GPUs

NVIDIA GeForce GT2XX Reference
Specifications, architecture, technologies, etc.

June 22, 2009 · Video cards: ATI GPUs

AMD(ATI) RADEON R(V)7XX Reference
Specifications, architecture, technologies, etc.

June 18, 2009 · Sound Cards

Creative Sound Blaster X-Fi Titanium Sound Cards
A hardware DSP and the PCI Express bus.

June 15, 2009 · Processors: AMD

AMD Phenom II 9xx CPUs With DDR3 Support
The first tests with the new test method.

  Latest News More   RSS  
  Useful Links Get listed  
 
iXBT Labs: Technology Reviews Widgets

Platform  ·  Video  ·  Multimedia  ·  Mobile  ·  Other  ·  Compare Prices  ||  Feedback  ·  Advertise at iXBT Labs  ·  About us  ·  Affiliates  ·  Forum


14

Copyright © Byrds Research & Publishing, Ltd., 1997—2009. All rights reserved.