iXBT Labs - Computer Hardware in Detail

Platform

Video

Multimedia

Mobile

Other

3Digest: 3D accelerators usability and prospect rating calculations for the end of the month




 



Thanks to:
Maxxx (maxm@online.sinor.ru),
Mikhail Sugakevitch (Mishail@newmail.ru)
Vjacheslav Gordeev AKA Slaydev (sarz@dale.elektra.ru) and
Ruslan73 (http://forum.ixbt.com/users.cgi?id=info:Ruslan73)
dmitro13 (dmytro13@hotmail.com)

UnVial (lvg@pop.ioffe.rssi.
ru)
Sergey Gaidukov (gsaf@sura.ru)
Mikhail Kuzmin (kuzmin@laser.ru)
for improving rating calculation method.

We have made significant changes to the rating calculation method for several reasons. Firstly, there was a number of math errors, so we decided to use geometrical average for all test results. Secondly, the quality value had little to no influence on the results. This was unacceptable due to newer games, in which AA or AF are very important. Thus we made AA and AF influence floating. The geometrical average performance is divided by 60 FPS (as a standard of average minimal sufficient performance) to obtain a coefficient of suitable performance. It's multiplied by a pre-fixed AA or AF coefficient that depends on certain card specs. This gives us a coefficient of card's AA or AF potential, that we finally take into consideration. Otherwise top-end cards would be underestimated, because when you spend $400-500, you get not only the FPS in existing games, but some potential for some higher quality in the future. Otherwise $10 cards made in 2002 could get high marks due to their low price).

Usability ratings are calculated by the following formula:

Kuse = ((K-no-AAA ) ^ (1/68))^ 0.6 * ((Poss ^ 0.4)) / (Price)) * 15000

where:

K-no-AAA - considers performance without AA+aniso.

K-no-AAA = (SS110xp * SS112xp * SS116xp) *
      (SS210xp * SS212xp * SS216xp) *
      (CJ10xp * CJ12xp * CJ16xp) *
      (SC110xp * SC112xp * SC116xp) *
      (SC210xp * SC212xp * SC216xp) *
      (CH10xp * CH12xp * CH16xp) *
      (FC110xp * FC112xp * FC116xp) *
      (FC210xp * FC212xp * FC216xp) *
      (PR10xp * PR12xp * PR16xp * PR25xp) *
      (G110xp * G112xp * G116xp) *
      (G210xp * G212xp * G216xp) *
      (G310xp * G312xp * G316xp) *
      (CR110xp * CR112xp * CR116xp) *
      (G1610xp * G1612xp * G1616xp) *
      (G2610xp * G2612xp * G2616xp) *
      (G3610xp * G3612xp * G3616xp) *
      (G4610xp * G4612xp * G4616xp)




K-with-AAA - considers performance with AA+aniso. Calculated using the same formula considering AA+aniso performance values.

The similar calculation (but for 1600x1200 resolution only) indicates the prospect of a videocard. The formula contains the same indexes as those used for usability rating calculations, but accelerator's price isn't considered. So, this rating indicates the capabilities of the current 3D cards in the current applications and future games.

You can also compare two ratings to see the correspondence of product prices to their capabilities and features.

According to the same scheme, but without 3DMark05/06 results, we calculated K-no-AAA-only-games and K-with-AAA-only-games coefficients for a games-only rating.

Legend:

  • Kuse - usability rating. The higher it is, the better card's mark is.
  • Kpro - prospect rating. The higher it is, the better card's mark is.
  • CJ10xp - Call Of Juarez at 1024x768x32, at max. quality;
  • CJ12xp - Call Of Juarez at 1280x1024x32, at max. quality;
  • CJ16xp - Call Of Juarez at 1600x1200x32, at max. quality;
  • FC110xp - FarCry (RESEARCH level) (No HDR) at 1024x768x32;
  • FC112xp - FarCry (RESEARCH level) (No HDR) at 1280x1024x32;
  • FC116xp - FarCry (RESEARCH level) (No HDR) at 1600x1200x32;
  • FC210xp - FarCry (RESEARCH level) (HDR) at 1024x768x32;
  • FC212xp - FarCry (RESEARCH level) (HDR) at 1280x1024x32;
  • FC216xp - FarCry (RESEARCH level) (HDR) at 1280x1024x32;
  • PR10xp - Prey at 1024x768x32;
  • PR12xp - Prey at 1280x1024x32;
  • PR16xp - Prey at 1600x1200x32;
  • G110xp - 3DMark05 Game1 at 1024x768x32;
  • G112xp - 3DMark05 Game1 at 1280x1024x32;
  • G116xp - 3DMark05 Game1 at 1600x1200x32;
  • G210xp - 3DMark05 Game2 at 1024x768x32;
  • G212xp - 3DMark05 Game2 at 1280x1024x32;
  • G216xp - 3DMark05 Game2 at 1600x1200x32;
  • G310xp - 3DMark05 Game3 at 1024x768x32;
  • G312xp - 3DMark05 Game3 at 1280x1024x32;
  • G316xp - 3DMark05 Game3 at 1600x1200x32;
  • G1610xp - 3DMark06 Game1 at 1024x768x32;
  • G1612xp - 3DMark06 Game1 at 1280x1024x32;
  • G1616xp - 3DMark06 Game1 at 1600x1200x32;
  • G2610xp - 3DMark06 Game2 at 1024x768x32;
  • G2612xp - 3DMark06 Game2 at 1280x1024x32;
  • G2616xp - 3DMark06 Game2 at 1600x1200x32;
  • G3610xp - 3DMark06 Game3 at 1024x768x32;
  • G3612xp - 3DMark06 Game3 at 1280x1024x32;
  • G3616xp - 3DMark06 Game3 at 1600x1200x32;
  • G4610xp - 3DMark06 Game4 at 1024x768x32;
  • G4612xp - 3DMark06 Game4 at 1280x1024x32;
  • G4616xp - 3DMark06 Game4 at 1600x1200x32;
  • F10xp - F.E.A.R. at 1024x768x32;
  • F12xp - F.E.A.R. at 1280x1024x32;
  • F16xp - F.E.A.R. at 1600x1200x32;
  • SC110xp - SCCT (No HDR) at 1024x768x32;
  • SC112xp - SCCT (No HDR) at 1600x1200x32;
  • SC116xp - SCCT (No HDR) at 1600x1200x32;
  • SC210xp - SCCT (HDR) at 1024x768x32;
  • SC212xp - SCCT (HDR) at 1600x1200x32;
  • SC216xp - SCCT (HDR) at 1600x1200x32;
  • CH10xp - Company of Heroes at 1024x768x32;
  • CH12xp - Company of Heroes at 1600x1200x32;
  • CH16xp - Company of Heroes at 1600x1200x32;
  • SS110xp - Serious Sam II (No HDR) at 1024x768x32;
  • SS112xp - Serious Sam II (No HDR) at 1600x1200x32;
  • SS116xp - Serious Sam II (No HDR) at 1600x1200x32;
  • SS210xp - Serious Sam II (HDR) at 1024x768x32;
  • SS212xp - Serious Sam II (HDR) at 1600x1200x32;
  • SS216xp - Serious Sam II (HDR) at 1600x1200x32;
  • Price - card price for the end of the month taken from price lists of a number of companies (for an average card);
  • Poss - estimated functional potential and quality of a videocard (see remarks below);

Poss is calculated by the following formula:

Poss = ((AF * AA) ^ (1/2) * (Driver * VS * PS) ^ (1/3)) / 100

Where:

  • Driver - estimated drivers quality (including installation difficulties, etc.) on the 10-mark scale.
  • AF - anisotropic filtering:
    • = 500 * (K-with-AAA ^ (1/68)) / 60 fps - Usual AF (GeForce 7xxx);
    • = 1000 * (K-with-AAA ^ (1/68)) / 60 fps - HQ AF (GeForce 8xxx/RADEON X1xxx);

  • AA - antialiasing (on condition of minimal gameplay):
    • = 500 * (K-with-AAA ^ (1/68)) / 60 fps - MSAA;
    • = 1000 * (K-with-AAA ^ (1/68)) / 60 fps - MSAA+SSAA;
    • = 1500 * (K-with-AAA ^ (1/68)) / 60 fps - MSAA+SSAA+TAA;
    • = 2500 * (K-with-AAA ^ (1/68)) / 60 fps - MSAA+SSAA+TAA+CSAA;

  • VS - hardware vertex shaders:
    • = 20 - version 3.0;
    • = 15 - version 2.0b;
    • = 5 - version 2.0;

  • PS - hardware pixel shaders:
    • = 20 - version 3.0;
    • = 15 - version 2.0b;
    • = 5 - version 2.0;

P.S. We understand that such way of making ratings is not perfect, therefore we await suggestions and comments from our readers to be considered in our next 3Digest.








04.03.2007


Article navigation:



blog comments powered by Disqus

  Most Popular Reviews More    RSS  

AMD Phenom II X4 955, Phenom II X4 960T, Phenom II X6 1075T, and Intel Pentium G2120, Core i3-3220, Core i5-3330 Processors

Comparing old, cheap solutions from AMD with new, budget offerings from Intel.
February 1, 2013 · Processor Roundups

Inno3D GeForce GTX 670 iChill, Inno3D GeForce GTX 660 Ti Graphics Cards

A couple of mid-range adapters with original cooling systems.
January 30, 2013 · Video cards: NVIDIA GPUs

Creative Sound Blaster X-Fi Surround 5.1

An external X-Fi solution in tests.
September 9, 2008 · Sound Cards

AMD FX-8350 Processor

The first worthwhile Piledriver CPU.
September 11, 2012 · Processors: AMD

Consumed Power, Energy Consumption: Ivy Bridge vs. Sandy Bridge

Trying out the new method.
September 18, 2012 · Processors: Intel
  Latest Reviews More    RSS  

i3DSpeed, September 2013

Retested all graphics cards with the new drivers.
Oct 18, 2013 · 3Digests

i3DSpeed, August 2013

Added new benchmarks: BioShock Infinite and Metro: Last Light.
Sep 06, 2013 · 3Digests

i3DSpeed, July 2013

Added the test results of NVIDIA GeForce GTX 760 and AMD Radeon HD 7730.
Aug 05, 2013 · 3Digests

Gainward GeForce GTX 650 Ti BOOST 2GB Golden Sample Graphics Card

An excellent hybrid of GeForce GTX 650 Ti and GeForce GTX 660.
Jun 24, 2013 · Video cards: NVIDIA GPUs

i3DSpeed, May 2013

Added the test results of NVIDIA GeForce GTX 770/780.
Jun 03, 2013 · 3Digests
  Latest News More    RSS  

Platform  ·  Video  ·  Multimedia  ·  Mobile  ·  Other  ||  About us & Privacy policy  ·  Twitter  ·  Facebook


Copyright © Byrds Research & Publishing, Ltd., 1997–2011. All rights reserved.