Today we will examine new models from Seagate, Maxtor and Samsung. Let me introduce the participants.

Maxtor

Maxtor 541DX

The 541DX line is a follower of the 531DX. It has the same reduced thickness, load/unload ramp, the acoustic system control circuit. At the same time, the recording density is 40 GBytes per platter (or, rather, 20 GBytes per side, since there is only one head in the discs of this series).

Samsung

Samsung SP4004H

Samsung SV3002H

The SP4004H is a disc with a spindle speed equal to 7200 rpm. The recording density is 20 GBytes per platter, the buffer size makes 2 MB. The model is of a 40 GBytes capacity. The line consists of 10, 20 and 30 GBytes models.

The SV3002H - is the latest model with a spindle speed being 5400 rpm. The recording density is 30 GBytes per platter, but the buffer size is only 512 KB. The line includes two models of 30 and 60 GBytes.

Both models have the proprietary shock-proff technologies: Shock Skin Bumper (SSB) and ImpacGuard which were described in the last review.

Seagate

Seagate Barracuda ATA IV

The hit of the review is the Seagate Barracuda ATA IV which impresses
us with 40 GBytes per platter and with the spindle speed equal to 7200 rpm! According to the press-releases, the developers have increased both a density of tracks on a platter and a data density on a track. The design has improved because, first, the case should be more rigid with such spindle speed and data density; secondly, it is now simpler to place internal shock-absorbers and noise-protecting screens.

A piece of the lower SeaShield can be seen on the photo. But on the other hand, the heat removal becomes worse with such screens. The Barracuda ATA IV disc is equipped also with a new engine serving for noise elimination as well: SoftSonic on the fluid dynamic bearings (FDB). As a result, the noise level of the new Barracuda (40 GBytes) makes only 2 bels when discs are rotating and 2.4 bels in case of searching transitions of the heads. We may say that the perfection is achieved since a human ear doesn't perceive sounds quieter than 2.5 bels. The line consists of 20, 40, 60 and 80 GBytes discs. The sample we tested had a capacity of 80 GBytes.

The complete characteristics are in the table.

Tests

The tests were carried out according to our testing technique.

Ziff-Davis WinBench 99 - 7200 rpm

Well, the data exchange rate has risen. The Barracuda keeps on leading. The most impressing results are achieved in the end of the disc in reading operations. The results of the Samsung's model are evident: at the beginning it is a bit better than the WD400BB, at the end - a bit worse.

Barracuda ATA IV

Samsung SP4004H

The Barracuda shows outstanding results! The first two zones take more than a half of the disc, and a reading speed here is 40 tb/s and higher. The SP4004H shows nothing extraordinary.

Well, the access time of the Barracuda has twice improved as compared with its predecessor! The gap separating this model and its competitors has now become narrower. The difference of the obtained results from the specified in the documentation (4.17 + 9 = 13.17 ms) is easy to explain. Such parameter as access time is measured with a special technological interface, that is why the interface delays outside are not taken into account.

The SP4004H performs quite well.

Now let's look at the operation in standard applications.

The High-End Disk WinMark has brought a victory to the Seagate and a defeat to the Samsung. Nevertheless, in the Business Disk WinMark the Barracuda seems to feel uncertain in the FAT32. However, the Samsung is more than just certain in the last place in the table...

Well, here the Seagate Barracuda ATA IV is a leader, while the Samsung SP4004H is outsider.

Ziff-Davis WinBench 99 - 5400 rpm

Since the results of the Maxtor 541DX do not depend on the acoustic management settings the results are given only for the mode with the acoustic management disabled. It should be noted that the acoustic management utility from Maxtor should be used carefully, or better left aside at all. We managed to enable the mode we wanted at the third attempt, at best. In all other cases the disc fell into some vague mode.

In the linear reading speed the Maxtor's disc falls behind only the Barracuda. The Samsung has nothing new to boast about. I think the approach here is the same as in the U6 - the larger capacity is achieved at the expense of the higher track density, while the speed is the same.

Maxtor 541DX

Samsung SV3002H

The Maxtor has almost ideal graph of reading, while on the graph of the Samsung you might notice a little saw.

Well, such a recording density makes the access time rise. Therefore, the results of the IOMeter test might be rather sad. The Samsung, on the contrary, will probably have good results in this test.

Now the Ziff-Davis Disk WinMarks tests. In the Business Disk WinMark the results depend on the access time, that is why the new Maxtor doesn't shine here. However, in the High-End Disk WinMark the Maxtor performs much better. For the Samsung the low results in the Disk WinMarks have become nearly a tradition. The increased buffer size doesn't improve the situation. It seems that the algorithms of operation with a cache-buffer are still raw.

The complete test results can be found in the table.

Intel IOMeter - 7200 rpm

The Samsung has unexpectedly approached the leader. So, if the data exchange rate is rather good according to the synthetic test, then why is it so poor in the ZD Disk WinMarks??? Maybe, the problem consists in the algorithms of operation with the buffer...

Intel IOMeter - 5400 rpm

The Samsung is again among leaders. The Maxtor is a loser; it falls behind even its predecessor.

The complete test results can be found in the table.

Noiseness

Loud discs today are too difficult to find. All our participants make much less noise than a fan of a power supply unit does. The Barracuda ATA IV is so noiseless that you will hardly hear anything even
when listening very close to the case.

Conclusion

The Seagate Barracuda ATA IV, as you may assume, is a new leader
among the discs with 7200 rpm spindle speed. The Maxtor 2B020H1 is the best choice for entry-level computers (high speed + moderate capacity + low price ($83 at Almer)). The Samsung discs made an ambivalent impression. In the Intel IOMeter test they are unquestioned
winners. But this is a synthetic test. In the tests based on real applications the discs are losers. The company should, probably, take the firmware development more seriously.

Write a comment below. No registration needed!